
Omar Minaya often gets criticized for the moves he's made, but this team is substantially better because of him.
BY ZACHARY SCHULMAN
STACHE WRITER
There is no doubt that Omar Minaya is a large part of the Mets Renaissance back into the public eye. Once Bobby Valentine was relieved of his duties (sad face) few Mets remember or choose not to remember the Art Howe years. Things took a turn for the better in the offseason after the 2004 season when Omar Minaya took to the helm of the Mets. His first big splash was signing Pedro Martinez to really inject life into what was a waning organization.
Though Martinez had only one Pedro-esque year on the field, winning 15 games in 2005, his intangible impact is what made him worth it. Since then Minaya has made several impact moves and others that weren’t quite as impactful. I will break down the current roster and try to divulge if Minaya deserves the brunt of the blame.
Jose Reyes and David Wright: Though they weren’t signed or drafted by Minaya he gave them the long term deals to avoid their arbitration years and make them they key parts of a championship driven team. PLUS
Carlos Delgado: While he originally spurned the Mets during his free agency period, to sign with division rivals the Marlins, Omar stood his ground and pull the trigger to get his big time power bat. Delgado was acquired for Mike Jacobs, who is an average player with some pop, Yusmeiro Petit, who was thought to be a great prospect, has struggled with Arizona and bounced up and down between AAA and the bigs, and lastly Grant Psomas, who is in the witness protection program. PLUS
Carlos Beltran: The move that has undoubtedly gotten the most press during Minaya’s tenure. Beltran signed a 7 year deal before the 2005 Season. His first year he struggled hitting 16 homers, but when Delgado was added to the lineup the next season, he has hit 109 homers 380 RBI and has been one of the best defensive players in the game. PLUS
Gary Sheffield: Sheffield has been reborn as a Met. He is tied for the team lead in homers with 8. He has given the team an edge and been a professional in the club house. Not to mention they are paying him 400 grand for this year.
Ryan Church and Brian Schneider: Minaya was familiar with these players from his time in Montreal. Church was the Mets best player last year until he got hurt. Schneider when healthy has been serviceable. They traded former first round pick Lastings Milledge, who they clearly wanted out of town. Milledge is currently in the Minor Leagues for the Nationals. PLUS
Luis Castillo: Castillo was brought in here as a pennant race move in 2007 to fortify the second base position. Castillo had 199 ABs as a Met in 2007 where he hit .296 with 20 RBI. This apparently warranted a 4 year deal. PLUS for the acquiring him in 2007, MINUS for resigning him for that many years and dollars
BENCH: CORA, SANTOS, TATIS, and REED are all plusses. Despite the struggles of Tatis this year, he was an integral part of the team’s success last year and brings class. Cora has become one of the leaders of the team and consistently plays ball the right way. Omir Santos has proven to be a major league catcher and has made fans forget about Ramon Castro. Reed has done everything asked of him, play solid defense, get some pinch hit, and spot start.
Onto the pitching staff:
Johan Santana: He was the necessary piece after the collapse of 2007. A bonified ace, he electrifies almost every time he takes the mound. He won 16 games last year with a shotty bullpen, he should have won about 23 games. This year, amidst some mid season struggles, continues to be the best pitcher in the NL and maybe all the game. He was traded for Phil Humber, Kevin Mulvey, Deolis Guerra, and Carlos Gomez. Gomez is a regular for the Twins, but all 3 pitching prospects dealt have yet to factor into the Twins big league club. PLUS
Mike Pelfrey: Omar Minaya’s first first round draft pick of as GM of the Mets, he struggled in his original go arounds as a Mets pitcher but had a solid 2008 where he won 13 games. Is now a mainstay in the rotation and should be for years to come. PLUS
John Maine: Though Injuries have taken their toll on him recently, he was acquired as a thrown in as part of the Kris Benson trade, which also netted Jorge Julio. Julio was promptly dealt to Arizona for El Duque. Maine has pitched well in big games and won 15 games in 2007. PLUS
Oliver Perez: Much like Maine, Perez was also a throw in, in a deal, which also brought Roberto Hernandez, for Xavier Nady. Perez pitched well in the post season in 2006 and like Maine again won 15 games in 2007. Has proven to be consistently inconsistent on the mound, which has been maddening to everyone watching. Walked 105 batters last year, won 10 games and had 4.22 era. As a result, he was awarded a 3 year 36 million dollar deal, and still can’t get people out consistently. He is currently rehabbing a balky knee in the minors. Much like Castillo, PLUS for trading for him, MINUS for giving him a megadeal.
Livan Hernandez: A tremendous bargain basement signing by Omar. The man knows how to pitch, pitches 200 plus innings every year, and can win big games. Has been the second best pitcher in the rotation this year.
K-Rod: Has been the best reliever in baseball this year. If not for him the Mets would likely be 10-12 games under 500. He is only 26 and set the ML record for saves in a season with 62. Signed a 3 year 37 million dollar deal, which is looking like a huge bargain. PLUS
JJ PUTZ and SEAN GREEN: The Jury is still out on these two. Putz clearly was pitching hurt all year and is now out until August recovering from surgery. Green has shown glimpses of the more polished Joe Smith that he was traded for. Let’s see how their numbers turn out at the end of the season.
Minaya has certainly made more positive moves for this team than negative. Yes he traded Heath Bell and Matt Lindstrom away for nothing. He missed out on Derek Lowe and Raul Ibanez. But he has gotten this team out of the doldrums it was in when he got there. And while there is little success to show for it, he has taken steps in the right direction. I do feel, however, that if a playoff run does not happen in the next couple of seasons, that Omar’s job is on the line.
No Comments